The Earnings Recession is Here
Christopher Norwood • July 17, 2023

Rising unemployment and slowing wage growth is the goal.

Recession is the Risk.

   

Market Update

The S&P 500 climbed 2.4% to finish the week at 4,505.42. The Nasdaq rose 3.3%. The two-year Treasury yield fell to 4.7% from above 5% the prior week. We wrote last week that, "Buyers couldn’t push the S&P above 4,440 (on Friday), although they tried for almost 45 minutes. Having failed to advance past 4,440, the S&P started falling around 1:30 p.m. and closed near its low for the day. Closing near its low on Friday means the selling is more likely to continue Monday.” The selling did continue Monday morning. The S&P traded down another 9 points before bottoming at 4,389.92 around noon. Monday’s low was the low for the week though.


The S&P advanced to 4,443.64 in the last fifteen minutes of trading on Tuesday. It closed at 4,439.26, below the 4,440 resistance. A target was set though with the temporary advance above 4,440. Remember, the S&P had tried for 45 minutes to advance past 4440 the prior Friday without success. The market ran into selling at that same 4,440 level on Tuesday. The algorithms took care of the resistance level at the open on Wednesday by gapping up to 4,470. The excuse was the better-than-expected inflation report released before the market opened. It was only an excuse though as traders battled in their zero-sum game of tug-of-war.


The Fed has made it clear that it will raise rates at the July 25-26 meeting. It has made it clear that it needs to see wage growth slow to 3.0% to 3.5% before it will declare victory in its inflation fight. It has made it clear that the CPI report would have no impact on its July decision. It has also made it clear that it may hike again depending on the next couple months of data.


Former Fed Vice chair Richard Clarida was on Bloomberg before the CPI report was released. He said unequivocally that the CPI report would have no impact on the Fed’s decision to raise in July. He was speaking for the Fed although no longer with the Fed. It is a common practice for the Fed to use former officials to get the word out. The market's gap up open was about the algorithms needing to vanquish 4,440 before profit taking set in. It was not about equity investors deciding to buy based on improving fundamentals.


But the drop in the two-year yield that began on July 6th does signal that bond investors expect a lower fed funds rate in 2024. (The two-year tracks the fed funds rate.) The two-year yield began falling the week before last, well in advance of the CPI report. A declining two-year yield lines up with the fed funds futures market.


The CME FedWatch tool is assigning a 93% chance of a rate hike in late July. A hike would take the fed funds rate to 5.25%-5.50%. There is a 70% chance that the funds rate will be at 5.25% or higher at year end. Investors are pricing in rate cuts after year-end, which lines up with a falling two-year yield. There is only a 25.7% chance of the fed funds rate being at 4% or higher by the end of 2024 according to the CME FedWatch tool. There is a 50.4% chance that the funds rate will be between 3.5% and 4% by year end 2024. That implies at least five 0.25% cuts by the end of 2024, assuming one more quarter point hike in July. Wall Street is betting on a quick reversal of Fed policy over the next 17 months. Such a sharp reversal will only occur in a recession.


Falling inflation is touted as the reason for the 2023 stock market rally. Yet the rally is about a handful of stocks. Seven stocks with a combined $11 trillion in market value contributed 73% of the first half gains, according to Barron’s. Apple, Microsoft, Amazon, Alphabet and Nvidia have a 47% weighting in the Nasdaq. Those five stocks make up 24.2% of the S&P 500. The Russell 1000 Value index is up 2.9% in 2023. The Russell 2000 (small cap) Value index is flat on the year. Falling inflation hasn't helped most stocks. Likewise, the big five are flying on AI hype not disinflation.


Most stocks haven’t gone anywhere for good reason. Earnings have been falling. S&P earnings declined 1.8% in Q4 2022. They fell 2.8% in Q1, are expected to fall 8.9% in Q2 and 0.5% in Q3. That is four quarters in a row of declining earnings. Small wonder that most stocks aren’t participating in the gains in 2023. There is good reason to expect continued pressure on earnings. Falling inflation means slower nominal GDP growth which means slower nominal revenue growth. Slower revenue growth means pressure on profit margins, all else equal. Pressure on profit margins means cost cutting which means layoffs. Falling inflation leads to falling real GDP growth as well then. The consumer is 70% of the economy. Consumers can’t consume for long without income.


But if falling inflation IS the reason for the rally then investors should brace themselves. There is a good chance that inflation will start rising again in the next few months. The CPI rose 1.2% in June of 2022. The June 2023 CPI gain was 0.2% which means inflation fell by 1% year-over-year. The CPI was unchanged in July 2022. The year-over-year number is set to rise in July 2023 if the monthly number is greater than zero. In fact, the annual change in the CPI will be 3.9% in December if monthly inflation reverts to its quantitative-easing-era average in the second half of 2023, according to Bianco Research. The stock and bond markets aren't prepared for rising inflation into year end.


“Any additional disinflationary momentum will have to come from slower month-over-month gains in core services prices,” Gregory Daco, chief economist at EY Parthenon, wrote recently. He believes that energy prices, food prices, and core goods prices have stopped falling, according to Barron’s. Core CPI is currently 4.8%. That is well above the Fed’s target of 2%. Average hourly earnings are growing at a 4.4% clip, too fast for inflation to fall to 2%.


The Fed’s favorite measure of inflation hasn’t moved much in over a year. The 12-month trimmed mean PCE inflation rate was 4.6% in May down a tick from 4.7% in December 2022. The six-month trimmed mean PCE inflation rate is 4.3% down marginally from 4.4%. The PCE index is unlikely to move much lower without a decline in wage growth. Chairman Powell has stated wage growth of 3.0% to 3.5% is enough to push inflation down to 2%. That will require a rise in unemployment. All roads lead back to a recession. It’s a question of when it begins.


Economic Indicators

The NFIB survey rose to 91 in June from 89.4 in May but remained well below its average of 98. Small business owners remained concerned about inflation and labor quality. The number of owners expecting better business conditions over the next six months rose 10% from May. Most owners are still negative on future business conditions though. “Halfway through the year, small-business owners remain very pessimistic about future business conditions and their sales prospects,” said NFIB Chief Economist Bill Dunkelberg.


The consumer price index rose 0.2% in June, better than the 0.3% forecast. The core CPI year-over-year rose 4.8% down from 5.3%. Core PPI rose 0.1% in June up from 0.0% the prior month. The core PPI year-over-year rose 2.6% down from 2.8%. The PPI is a leading indicator of the CPI.

 

 

The Risk Premium Revisited

We wrote last week about the equity risk premium. An investor should expect a higher return from a riskier investment. The risk premium for stocks versus bonds has averaged between 3.0% and 3.5% over the last 20 years or so. It has averaged closer to 4.5% going back to the late 1800s. Currently, the risk premium is only around 1.1%.


One of Barron’s Roundtable guests referenced risk premium in this week’s edition. Rupal J. Bhansali is chief investment officer and portfolio manager of international and global equity strategies for Ariel Investments. She manages billions of dollars at Ariel.


Bhansali told Barron’s in this week’s edition that, “The U.S. 10-year Treasury yield is approaching 4%, and equity risk premiums should be at least 300 basis points above that to compensate for higher risk. This implies a 7% earnings yield on the S&P 500, or a price/earnings multiple of 14.28 times." She went on to point out that the S&P would need to trade down to 2856 for the equity risk premium to rise to 7%, assuming a recession and double-digit decline in earnings. The S&P would need to trade down to around 3,141 if current earnings forecasts are accurate. The S&P is currently above 4,500.


Small Caps Are Cheap

Ed Clissold, chief U.S. strategist at Ned Davis Research notes that the S&P 600’s earnings yield – the inverse of the index’s price/earnings ratio – is near a record low versus the S&P 500’s.


Monetary Tightening Without Rate Cuts

It is the real interest rate that counts. High real rates are restrictive. Negative real rates have been the norm for years now (free money). The real interest rate is the nominal rate minus inflation. The nominal rate is what you pay or receive. You need to subtract inflation from that amount to understand the true cost of money.


The Fed’s Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) shows a year end Fed funds rate of 5.6%. The Fed is forecasting a core PCE rate of 3.9% by year end. Based on the funds rate and PCE forecasts the real interest rate will be 1.7% by year end. The real interest rate will continue to increase as inflation falls. Monetary policy will tighten without rate cuts. The real rate will continue to rise even as the Fed starts cutting rates should the inflation rate fall faster than the funds rate. In other words, monetary easing might not happen as quickly as it did in the low-inflation era.


In past cycles the average Fed pause from the last rate hike to the first cut was eight months. In every case the stock market did not bottom until 13 to 33 months after the last hike. (see chart above). We can expect a continuation of tightening as the Fed hikes in July. We can expect further tightening after that because of falling inflation regardless of whether the Fed hikes a second time.


It will likely be next spring at the earliest before the Fed starts cutting. And then only if a recession has materialized. A stock market bottom isn’t likely to occur until at least August of 2024 if the July hike is the last. The questions are: What does the stock market do before it begins to price in a recession? And when does it begin to price in the recession?


Oh, and let's not forget about Quantitative Tightening. Equity investors are in a high-risk environment. Risk management is paramount.


Regards,


Christopher R Norwood, CFA


Chief Market Strategist

By Christopher Norwood October 20, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.7% last week to finish at 6664.01 The Nasdaq & the Dow Jones rose as well last week We had an inside day last Monday, then an inside week Earnings season is here The four credit events might snowball into something more serious Credit spreads have started to react, widening over the last two weeks Bond yields fell (yields down, price up) last week The dollar index is also falling The Federal Reserve has been draining excess reserves from the system since 2022 It appears as if the Fed has no choice but to end its Quantitative Tightening (QT) program The Stock Market The S&P 500 rose 1.7% last week to finish at 6664.01. The Nasdaq 100 was up 2.4% and the Dow was up around 1.5%.
By Christopher Norwood October 13, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500, Nasdaq & the Dow Jones fell last week President Trump tanked the market Friday with a post about trade talk troubles with China The S&P 500 still has a lot of momentum, though Bond investors aren’t expecting a recession any time soon The Atlanta Fed GDPNow tool is estimating 3.8% real GDP growth for Q3 The AI boom is increasingly dependent on circular cash flows The U.S. stock market has a lot of exposure to AI The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood October 6, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.1% to close the week at 6715.79 The Nasdaq was down 0.3% last week The Dow Jones Industrial Average was up 1.99%. The government shutdown materialized on Wednesday The Fed is expected to cut the funds rate by another quarter point in October Unemployment isn’t rising, and consumers are still spending Recession red flags The last 18 years have been unusual A recession is not Norwood Economics’ base case
By Christopher Norwood September 29, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.3% last week to finish at 6,643.66 The Dow, Nasdaq, and Tech sector ended lower as well The S&P average annual total return is 7.9% since the 2000 market peak The economy grew 3.8% in Q2 (third estimate), up from the prior 3.3% second estimate Financial conditions remain loose The 10-year Treasury yield has little room to fall from current levels The elderly and poor suffer most from the impacts of inflation Norwood Economics manages diversified portfolios This time is NOT different The S&P might see negative returns over the next decade Economic growth is the lowest in the past 25 years There are no piles of cash sitting on the sidelines The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood September 22, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.2% last week to finish at 6,664.36 The S&P 500 is up 13.31% year-to-date The S&P is expensive The Fed updated its “Dot Plot” The 10-year yield rose last week despite the Fed’s rate cut The Fed is signaling at least two more rate cuts by year's end A pullback of 10% or so wouldn’t be unusual, but there’s no data signaling recession yet The top ten most expensive S&P 500 companies make up over 39% of the market cap UBS economists estimate a 93% chance that the US will slip into a recession this year Investors should review their portfolios before the next bear market The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood September 15, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.6% last week to finish at 6,584.3 The stock market rises long-term due to earnings growth and interest rates A stock is ownership in a business Investors are willing to pay more for a dollar’s worth of earnings today than in the past Profit margins are already near record highs The Volatility Index (VIX) closed the week at 14.76 The market is setting new highs The CME FedWatch tool places the odds at 100% for a rate cut Wednesday The August jobs report and last week’s jobs revision are driving rate cut expectations Cutting the fed funds rate isn’t the answer to slower job growth Higher long-term rates will negate any benefit from a rate cut The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood September 8, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.3% last week to finish at 6,481.50 The CAPE ratio is currently at its second highest reading ever Valuation is a lousy timing mechanism, but an excellent predictor of future returns Interest rates declined last week The 2-Year Treasury yield fell to 3.51% by the close on Friday The 10-Year Treasury yield also fell, ending the week at 4.10%. The CME FedWatch tool has the odds at 73% of a Fed funds rate of 3.50% to 3.75% or lower by year's end The weak jobs report on Friday showed that only 22,000 new jobs were added in August Unemployment rose to 4.3% from 4.2%. The aggregate weekly payrolls index fell to 4.4% in August “We’re back in that world of uncertainty," states Art Hogan, chief market strategist at B. Riley Wealth  The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood September 2, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 finished down 0.1% at 6,460.26 last week The S&P is up 9.8% on the year. Industrials and Communication Services are leading the way Personal income rose in line with expectations for July, climbing 0.4% up from 0.3% the prior month A weak payroll number on 5 September means a Fed rate cut on 17 September Unemployment is expected to rise, but it is still low relative to history Wage growth close to 4% will make it hard for inflation to fall to 2% The predictions market has the odds of a recession at 8% The ICE BofA US High Yield Index spread is near all-time lows A bear steepener is increasingly likely. A bear steepener is when the yield curve falls at the short end but rises at the long end
By Christopher Norwood August 25, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 0.3% last week to close at 6466.91 The CME FedWatch tool initially raised the chances of a September rate cut to 84.7% The stock and bond markets opted to buy Fed Chairman Powell’s Friday morning speech Investors now seem certain that the Fed will start cutting again The current five-year breakeven is 2.48% The 10-year breakeven is 2.41% The core Consumer Price Index (CPI) is 3.1% Disinflation appears to be over as the inflation rate is no longer falling The St Louis Fed’s Financial Stress Index is negative 0.8153. A negative number means below-average financial market stress The real 10-year interest rate is falling. Money is getting cheaper. The Fed’s balance sheet is shrinking, but is still 22% of GDP An indebted economy can’t withstand high interest rates  The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood August 18, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.01% last week to finish at 6,449.80 The stock market keeps hitting new highs Market strategists are expecting earnings growth to accelerate in 2026 Margins remain near record highs Corporate profit margins will likely take a hit from tariffs Passing tariff costs on to the consumer means raising prices Core CPI rose by 0.3% in July The PPI jumped 0.9% last month, the largest monthly increase in more than three years Buffett says it’s dangerous when the market cap rises to more than 140% of GDP. Currently, the ratio is above 200%. The massive increase in the Fed's balance sheet over the last 25 years has led to financial asset price inflation The Stock Market