Value Stocks Always Make a Comeback
Christopher Norwood • December 23, 2024

Executive Summary

  • The Stock Market dropped 2% last week 
  • The Dow ended its losing streak at 10
  • The Fed cut interest rates by a quarter-point last Wednesday
  • Fewer rate cuts could mean slower economic growth and slower earnings growth
  • Apollo’s chief economist Torsten Sløk predicts a 40% chance of Fed rate hikes in 2025
  • Value stocks continue to lag growth stocks and the overall market
  • Value will make a comeback. It always does.
  • History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes~ Mark Twain

S&P 500 5-day chart

Market Update/Economic Update

It was an ugly week for the stock market. The S&P dropped 2%, finishing at 5,930.85. According to Barron's, the Nasdaq fell 2.1%, and the Dow lost 2.6% last week. On Monday, the Dow suffered its eighth straight day of declines even as the Nasdaq was hitting a record high. Barron’s wrote that something like that had never happened before. The Dow’s losing streak eventually extended to 10 days. It was its longest since 1974. The losing streak ended Thursday with a small gain for the Dow.



Wednesday was particularly bad with volatility skyrocketing.

VIX 3-month chart

The Fed’s interest rate decision came Wednesday afternoon. The quarter-point cut was expected. The hawkish Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) was not. The blue-chip index sank 1,123 points or 2.6%. The S&P 500 dropped 2.95%. The Nasdaq Composite fell 3.6%. All 11 S&P 500 sectors fell on the same day for the first time since the Aug. 5 market selloff. Wednesday also saw the 12th day in a row where the number of decliners exceeded advancers within the S&P 500. This is the second longest run in 100 years and has only been exceeded by a run of 14 days in 1978, according to Barron’s.

S&P 500 3-month chart

Wednesday the S&P 500 fell below both the 20-day and the 50-day moving averages (see chart above). Thursday and Friday saw a battle between bears and bulls. The S&P gapped up at the open on Thursday to just below the 50-day moving average. It was unable to climb above and maintain. It eventually closed near its low for the day. The setup for Friday was negative given Thursday’s early high and late low. The futures market was signaling an ugly opening Friday morning before the open. The S&P did open down but then reversed, setting the low for the day in the first 15 minutes of trading. The index peaked at noon before giving back some ground. It was unable to retake the 50-day which sits at Friday’s close of 5,930. Monday could see a battle to retake the 50-day moving average and restart the Santa Claus rally. The odds favor a positive finish to the year, given the market’s momentum.


January is uncertain because...


The central bank was even more hawkish with its Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) update than had been anticipated. The September SEP had signaled four rate cuts in 2025. The December SEP is signaling only two cuts. In reaction, the benchmark 10-year yield jumped 9 basis points to 4.50% in afternoon trade. The shorter-end, more rate-sensitive 2-year yield spiked 10 basis points to 4.36%. The two-year yield ended the week at 4.32%. The 10-year yield finished the week at 4.52%.


Fewer rate cuts could mean slower economic growth and slower earnings growth. The Fed’s new forecast acknowledges that the economy doesn’t need short-term rate cuts. The FOMC’s projections see its preferred inflation gauge (the PCE) ending 2025 at 2.5%. That is well above the Fed’s 2% target. "The main takeaway from today’s Fed meeting was that inflation risks are back, and the Fed is concerned," writes Charlie Ripley, senior investment strategist at Allianz Investment Management. 


Barron’s summed it up nicely in this week’s edition:


“The economy is growing steadily, faster than the FOMC’s estimate of the economy’s potential of 1.8%. Inflation is above the Fed’s 2% target, while unemployment is at the committee’s estimated long-term equilibrium of 4.2%. Financial conditions remain exuberant, with rich equity valuations and tight credit spreads. And the only near certainty about the new administration’s policies is that they will tend to boost growth and inflation, all else being equal.”


At the same time, the SEP projects real gross domestic product growing by 2.1% in 2025. It had forecasted growth of 2.0% in September. The committee also had to boost its projection for GDP growth in 2024 to 2.5% from 2.0%. And that was before the big upward revision in this year’s third-quarter real GDP growth. Q3 GDP growth was raised to an annualized 3.1% up from 2.8%. The increase was mainly due to stronger personal spending. Also, the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow fourth-quarter estimate rose Wednesday to 3.2% from 3.1%.


Forget about rate cuts in 2025. Apollo’s chief economist Torsten Sløk wrote Thursday that he sees a 40% chance of Fed rate hikes in 2025 instead.



Meanwhile, the U.S. Dollar Index was on pace for its highest close in two years Wednesday. The dollar was responding to the Fed's go-slow rate cut expectations for 2025. The U.S. Dollar Index hit a high of 108.541 Wednesday setting a new 52-week high. The index ended the week at 107.815. Wednesday's close was the highest since Nov. 21, 2022, according to Dow Jones Market Data.

Dollar Index 2-year chart

Meanwhile, value stocks continue to lag the market and growth stocks. The Invesco S&P 500 Pure Value ETF (RPV) fell 4% last week. It dropped 7.8% in December, far more than the S&P, which is down 1.7% on the month. The Pure Value ETF trades at 10.1 times 12-month forward earnings. That is well below the S&P 500’s 21.6 times and the Invesco S&P 500 Pure Growth ETF (RPG) 23.8 times. Value will make a comeback. It always does. We wrote last week, “Value outperforms over the long run. The data is conclusive.” We offered up the chart below as evidence last week.

Here is a second chart that shows 10-year rolling returns. The value premium is evident (orange line). The two red areas denote rolling 10-year periods in which growth outperformed value.

Growth outperformed value during 10-year rolling periods in the 1930s and 2010s. The reason is likely the same for both eras. Extreme economic hardship during the Great Depression and Great Recession led to extreme monetary and fiscal policy. Value will outperform growth once again when monetary and fiscal policy normalizes. Normal will include 10-year Treasury yields around their long-term average of 4.5%. Normal will also include 30-year mortgages between 6% and 7% (about where they are now).


Meanwhile, a broad group of value stocks tracked by SentimenTrader senior analyst Jason Goepfert is near its lowest level versus growth in over two decades. The last time relative prices were at these levels was in the early 2000s. Value stocks went on to outperform growth in the first decade of the 2000s.


History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes, said Mark Twain. History may be getting ready to rhyme once again.


Regards,



Christopher R Norwood, CFA


Chief Market Strategist

By Christopher Norwood July 21, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 0.6% last week to finish at 6,296.79 The 2-Year trended lower, ending the week yielding 3.88% The 10-year Treasury yield ended the week at 4.44% Investors are nervous about tariffs and their impact Tariffs are coming directly out of the pockets of the US businesses that import the goods Rising inflation expectations only increases the chances of higher inflation and interest rates Continue to buy good companies on sale
By Christopher Norwood July 14, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.3% to close the week at 6,259.75 We would rather own the German economy than Nvidia Consumer spending is weakening The consumer price index report will be released on Tuesday Economists believe that tariffs will cause prices to rise Economists believe that tariffs will slow the economy The jobs market is stable. The unemployment rate is low. Earnings estimates are falling more than is normal There are still good companies on sale The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood July 7, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.7% in a holiday-shortened week, finishing at 6,284.65 Volatility continues to fall from its elevated levels in early April The S&P is up 6.76% year-to-date. Industrials are leading the way, up 13.40% Price determines returns when buying an asset  Diversify away from a concentrated U.S. large-cap stock portfolio Job growth has been holding steady for almost a year now Analysts have been raising earnings estimates recently 90-day tariff suspension ends on Wednesday The Stock Market The S&P 500 rose 1.7% in a holiday-shortened week. The Nasdaq rose 1.6%. Both indexes set new record highs with the S&P reaching 6,284.65 on Thursday afternoon. The jobs report out Thursday spurred the S&P higher. The index gapped up at the open, closing Thursday up 0.83% (see chart below). The S&P 500 is up 26% from the selloff low on April 8, while the Nasdaq has surged 34.9%.
By Christopher Norwood June 30, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 3.4% last week, climbing to 6,173.07 The Magnificent 7 are outperforming the S&P 493 by over 18% since April The Cboe Volatility Index (VIX) fell as low as 16.11 last week Investors seem unconcerned about tariffs and war Treasury interest rates are starting to fall The Fed has little reason to cut if unemployment isn't moving higher The stock market is at record highs Corporate bond spreads are tight, meaning credit is abundant The dollar has fallen by around 10% in 2025 Inflation is expected to move higher because of tariff The Stock Market The S&P 500 rose 3.4% last week. The Israeli-Iranian ceasefire was credited with the surge to the upside. The index had lost 0.7% over the prior two weeks.
By Christopher Norwood June 23, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 gained 0.3% last week, climbing to 5,967.84 The index is having trouble staying above 6,000 Technical indicators are turning somewhat negative The Federal Reserve kept the overnight rate at 4.25% - 4.50% The updated “dot plot” shows a divided Fed Seven members indicate no rate cuts in 2025 Eight members forecast two rate cuts in 2025 The Fed is forecasting a slower economy in 2025 and 2026 The hard data is starting to point to a slowing economy Inflation is still well above the Fed’s 2% target
By Christopher Norwood June 16, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 0.4% last week to finish at 5,976.97 Friday's sell-off due to Israel's attack on Iran The Volatility Index (VIX) is rising due to the war in the Middle East Higher volatility is usually associated with a down move in the market There is no chance of a Fed Funds Rate cut at this week’s meeting according to the CME FedWatch Tool The unemployment rate has been rising slowly The dollar continues to weaken The U.S. needs to reduce its spending to avoid a currency crisis  The Stock Market
By Christopher Norwood June 9, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.5% last week to finish at 6,000.36 The May payroll number came in above estimates The U.S. economy is slowing, despite the S&P 500 poking above 6,000 The Labor Force Participation Rate fell to 62.4% from 62.6% Inflation may have bottomed and is set to rise The services price paid index is pointing towards a higher CPI The declining dollar is a concern Tariffs are a tax The Q2 nowcast seems to be indicating that negative economic impacts from tariffs won’t affect Q2 International markets have far outperformed U.S. markets so far in 2025 The Stock Market The S&P 500 climbed 1.5% last week and closed at 6,000.36. The Dow rose 1.3% while the Nasdaq rose 2.0%. Interest rates rose as bond prices fell. A stronger-than-expected jobs report on Friday is getting the blame for rising yields. The jobs report was also responsible for the S&P’s gap-up open on Friday (chart below).
By Christopher Norwood June 2, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 1.9% last week to finish at 5911.69 The S&P 500 rose 6%, the Dow rose 3.8% and the Nasdaq climbed nearly10% in May Could see another test of support around 5,800 this week Several longer-term negative divergences may be pointing to a tough summer Declining new highs during an advancing market is a negative Earnings estimates for 2025 and 2026 have been trending lower Earnings drive the stock market over the long run
By Christopher Norwood June 2, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 fell 2.6% last week to close at 5,802.82. The 20-Year Treasury auction went poorly. The yield rose above 5%. The 5% threshold has twice this year resulted in the administration adjusting its stance on tariffs. (Make that three times as Trump over the weekend gives the U.K. until July 9 th .) Longer-term inflation expectations are rising. Moody’s downgraded the U.S. to Aa1 on 16 May. The credit default swaps market sees the U.S. as a Baa1/BBB+ credit, on par with Greece. The tax cut bill will add to the deficits and debt. Long-term interest rates might well continue to rise.
By Christopher Norwood May 19, 2025
Executive Summary The S&P 500 rose 5.3% last week to finish at 5,958.38 The Dow advanced 3.4% and the Nasdaq added 7.2% A falling VIX means investor confidence is increasing A 90-day pause in the trade war sent the S&P higher Earnings estimates are falling along with GDP growth forecasts Earnings and interest rates drive the stock market over the long run Investors are chasing performance Small business hiring plans and job openings haven’t improved Norwood Economics continues to look for good companies on sale The Stock Market